The Noble Story of Monsters, and Selective Ostrichism
And How Some People Will Always Look For Monsters In The Wrong Place
Because I don’t yet believe myself to have been corrupted by a flawed ideology, and because I don’t currently suffer from the malediction of cognitive dissonance, I feel it only appropriate that I continue on this moral crusade by addressing the recent mini-controversy now brushed under the mass-produced carpet. It concerns an artist called James Earley and an artwork about Monsters that he hung at The Other Art Fair, a counter-fair that features artists and not galleries. The news broke earlier this week. Because I abhor social media I naturally came to it 3 days later. [1]
Background
The furore centred upon Earley’s portrait, entitled “Monster”. A simple artistic analysis tells you that it’s a double portrait, painted by Earley himself, and featuring the stiched-together faces of notorious mid-century genocidal mass-murderer, Benjamin Netanyahu, and staunch defender of the only de-facto Jewish state in the world, Adolf Hitler.
As a conscientious individual, I believe in the moral obligation to attribute and acknowledge original research and articles. To whit, The Jewish Chronicle Online had already reported on Earley’s Monsters artwork, and noted Earley’s previous attempt at an oh-so-clever reframing of the Holocaust within a Brand New Context, which I’ll also address.
So, to repeat what has already been reported, Earley put up his Monsters painting for sale in a booth at The Other Art Fair. The Monsters painting was remarked upon by visitors to TOAF, who submitted feedback to the organisers, who in turn contacted Earley to request that he remove the offence. In a statement submitted to Jewish News Online, which I quote verbatim below:
And this statement was given to the JC Online:
The Pink elephant
Earley states that he is not antisemitic. However, there is an enormous pink elephant in the room, and it’s a simple word. Here it is:
Benjamin Netanyahu is Jewish.
Benjamin Netanyahu is the Prime Minister of Israel.
Israel is the only de-facto Jewish state in the world.
Israel is neighboured by six Arab countries where Islam is the dominant religion, with Iran within rocket-firing range.
The artwork compares a Jew to the pre-eminent mass murderer of Jews in recent history.
Honestly, I think I could end the article here. But I’m not one given to knowingly underusing words.
Calling out the holocaust, but not the monsters you think
Prior the Monsters piece, and to Earley’s credit, I did indeed find an artwork that depicted what on the surface appeared to be “calling out the horrors of the Holocaust“. [5] Only, peculiarly, the skin colour of the three girls depicted was slightly darker than one might have expected for Europeans who originated from colder climates. Oh, and the striped pyjamas featured a flag, rather than a geometric shape. And the internment number starts with a “G”.
Earley also painted a portrait of the 14-year old Polish Catholic girl Czeslawa Kwoka, who was murdered by the Nazis at Auschwitz, and whose internment portrait is listed on the website Faces of Auschwitz. [6] Earley’s artwork description is below. There is no mention of that naughty German regime, simply the anodyne sobriquet, “Auschwitz Scientists”. [7] One should note that the child, Kwoka, was murdered for her beliefs by a race-obsessed machine, hell-bent on eliminating all races it deemed sub-human. It did not distinguish between a Jew and a Catholic child of Jesus because Jesus was born a Jew.
The Nazi regime operated under the simple racist metric Aryan = Good. Why, then, would you list this artwork under the series “War and Conflict” and not “Racism and Colonialism”?
"Will No One Rid Me Of These Meddlesome Monsters?"
I would argue that an artist, much like a photographer, naturally takes a position or a stance prior to putting oil to canvas. Where the photographer physically only shows one side of an event, by turning his lens towards and his back away, so an artist responds similarly by depicting, through this plastic medium, the event which he has chosen. In fact, since the production of a painting arguably requires more hours to render a finished product than a photograph, one might postulate that the artist is even further entrenched in the ideology that spurs him on to complete said painting.
The original sin at the heart of the painting was the fact that a Jew’s face had been artistically merged with the preeminent individual responsible for mass murder of Jews in the 20th century. There is another element at work in the text, which reads: “The true story of how Monsters were created and how we defeated them.” You might argue that text is secondary to the visual elements in a work of art, I would disagree. Everything is placed for a reason.
Hitler, obviously, is very dead. He committed suicide in his private Fuhrenbunker on April 30, 1945. [8] Benjamin Netanyahu, however, is very alive. Thus, a quandary. Why did the artist use this specific language in his painting? What was his intention? What does it imply? I feel as though I’m drafting a high-school exam sheet.
Censorship?
After TOAF had received the complaints, made the request that the Monsters piece be removed, TOAF submitted a statement on the Monster issue to the JC Online, which I quote verbatim below:
So then Earley removed all his artworks from the booth, left TOAF, and made a statement on social media and his website about censorship.
If you submit a piece of work to a public forum, you sign a contract with that organisation to abide by its terms and conditions. If its T&Cs contains language that prohibits you from posting, uploading, publishing, submitting, or transmitting any text, graphics, images, software, music, audio, video, information or other material that promotes discrimination, bigotry, racism, hatred, harassment or harm against any individual or group, and you knowingly contravene those T&Cs, then the organisation reserves the right to remove the offending piece from its property. [10]
That is not censorship.
One might ask if, when submitting an artwork to a public art fair, an artist might be aware of the art fair’s T&Cs. I would posit that an intelligent individual does due diligence. Earley would also appear to manage an art gallery in Winchester, which might suggest a certain familiarity with contractual obligations. [11] So, Yes. What, therefore, could be an artist’s motivation for submitting an artwork so clearly in breach?
15 seconds of internet fame.
The ethics of power and the male gaze
It does seem pertinent to the vein of this article to address the ethical concerns of depicting and subsequently profiting off artwork that depicts human suffering. The history of photography is no stranger to this dilema; from Roger Fenton to the FSA, to W. Eugene Smith and Nick Ut, we have required of photographers to capture the depths of human despair and suffering. The difference, of course, is that the photographers I have cited here were commissioned or employed to produce this work.
If we delve further into the complexities of the male/female encounter we approach a dilemma. Feminist theorist Laura Mulvey introduced us to the concept of a “male gaze”. [12] This derived from her essay, Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema in which Mulvey proposed that there existed two types of gaze: one that was active and therefore male, and another that was passive and thus female. To put it in simpler terms, the female is looked at, while the male engages in the active pursuit of looking. Then as the viewer, or voyeur, you necessarily adopt the male point-of-viewing.
The reason I raise this ethical concern is that an artist has a responsibility to the individuals he chooses to depict. One might argue that profiting off a vulnerable individual is exploitation, another might argue that is constitutes art. The line is… blurred.
So if a respectable-looking male happens upon a woman in a state of distress, she appears to be homeless, say, and speaks to her (perhaps takes a photograph of her, perhaps not) then paints a portrait of her and sells the resulting work, can we say that the encounter was entirely uncoerced?
Proceeds of print sales from the War and Conflict series go to charity (Action Aid). It is unclear whether proceeds from the Homelessness series are donated to homelessness charities.
Fallout?
So what is the current status of “Monsters”? A generic Google search (“james + earley + monster”) brings up expected results ranging from third-party platforms like ArtFinder and Artsper to Earley’s own social media channels and website, and Jewish News. [13] Interestingly, the link to “Monster (2025) Oil painting by James Earley” no longer exists on Artfinder or Artsper.
The work appears as SOLD to a private collection on Earley’s website. It does not appear on websites Artfinder or Artsper, despite the links still being active in aforementioned generic Google search. A cursory scroll through Earley’s Artfinder profile finds that paintings that are SOLD are nonetheless still listed. [14] “Monsters” is not listed amongst them.
Should you wish to purchase a print of the painting, you may do so from the “Racism & Colonialism” section of the website.
Conclusion?
When Arabs kills Arabs no one paints a big fancy canvas, displays it in a public space, and creates a shit-ton of media attention because it’s not Jews. And you say that Jews run the media. [15]
But Netanyahu, and Israel by extension, seem to represent a perverse, almost fetishistic, exception to those who would consider themselves totally above moral reproach. These may be the same people who think Che Guevara was a good idea. Because it’s not that Communism was a massive fucking mistake, it’s that it just hasn’t been done properly yet. Although, in an ironic twist that has been deliberately ignored by the meanstream legacy media and fanatical nutbars that still wouldn’t recognise an Islamic global terror threat to the security of the Western world if it blew up in their faces, drove cars into markets, or stabbed soldiers in the streets, the kibbutzim that were systematically razed to the ground on 7 October 2023 represented the purest form of Communism. Shared responsibility, shared property, shared governance. Okay, but they were Jews, so they don’t count. [16]
So talk about monsters. But is it this man, or is it those he describes? [17]
References
- I provide now a polite disclaimer prior to kick-off. This edition of TFG aims to provide an artistic critique of the painting, and further raises valid ethical concerns regarding the concept of male influence and power, particularly when it concerns males in positions of power. I may also call out hypocrisy.
- The true story of how Monsters were created and how we defeated them (2024) by James Earley
- Michelle Rosenberg, “Artist stands by Netanyahu-Hitler painting after exhibition ban” (Jewish News online, March 10, 2025) https://www.jewishnews.co.uk/artist-defends-netanyahu-hitler-painting-after-exhibition-ban/ [last accessed 14 March 2025]
- Imogen Garfinkel, “Painting comparing Netanyahu to Hitler removed from Saatchi art fair amid outrage” (Jewish Chronicle UK, 7 March 2025) https://www.thejc.com/news/uk/painting-comparing-netanyahu-to-hitler-removed-from-saatchi-art-fair-amid-outrage-faunbv3p [last accessed 13 March 2025]
- Keith Huxen, “The Death of Adolf Hitler”, (The National World War II Memorial Museum, New Orleans website, 30 March 2020) https://www.nationalww2museum.org/death-of-adolf-hitler [last accessed 19 March 2025]
- Paintings by James Earley https://www.jamesearleyartist.com/limited-edition-prints/war-conflict-series-limited-edition-prints/ [last accessed 14 March 2025]
- Czeslawa Kwoka (Gallery, Faces of Auschwitz) https://facesofauschwitz.com/gallery/czeslawa-kwoka/ [last accessed 14 March 2025]
- Artist statement, Czeslawa Kwoka: https://www.jamesearleyartist.com/paintings/war-conflict-paintings-series/czeslawa-kwoka-portrait-painting/ [last accessed 14 March 2025]
- “Painting comparing Netanyahu to Hitler removed from Saatchi Fair amid outrage”, March 7, 2025: https://www.thejc.com/news/uk/painting-comparing-netanyahu-to-hitler-removed-from-saatchi-art-fair-amid-outrage-faunbv3p [last accessed 14 March, 2025]
- Terms of Use (The Other Art Fair, 1 February 2021) https://www.theotherartfair.com/the-other-art-fair-terms-of-use/ [last accessed 17 March 2025]
- Toby Oliver, “Castle Fine Art Winchester opens” (Hampshire Chronicle, 2 July 2024) https://www.hampshirechronicle.co.uk/news/24422272.castle-fine-art-winchester-opens-doors-former-cafe-dinghams/ [last accessed 19 March 2025]
- Laura Mulvey, “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema”, Screen, Vol. 16, no. 3, Autumn 1975, pp. 6-18 (p. 11)
- Google search results (Google, 14 March 2025) [last accessed 14 March 2025]
- James Earley artist profile (Artfinder) https://www.artfinder.com/artist/jamesearley/page-8 [last accessed 19 march 2025]
- Lord Roberts et al., “7 October Parliamentary Commission Report” (7octparliamentarycommission) https://www.7octparliamentarycommission.co.uk/ [last accessed 18 March 2025]
- Statement delivered by Luai Ahmed to United Nations Human Rights Council, reported within “When Arabs kills millions of Arabs, no one bats an eye” (UN Watch, 1 March 2025) https://unwatch.org/yemeni-activist-asks-un-why-is-it-when-arabs-kill-millions-of-arabs-no-one-bats-an-eye/ [last accessed 19 March]
- Benjamin Netanyahu, “PM Netanyahu: Who kidnaps a little boy and a baby and murders them? Monsters. That’s who.” (YouTube, 21 February 2025) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUZfVdiMvQc [last accessed 19 March 2025]
Would you like to share this with the world?
- Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
- Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
- Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

